Letter: Despite hyperbole, lawsuit not about shuttering base

Editor,

The Bounce-on-Whidbey group is ramping up its rhetoric and scaring politicians into uncomfortable corners. Emerging within the ramp-up is a healthy level of irrationality, the sky-will-fall prognostications, seventh grade playground labels assigned to our nationally respected AG, insistence that it’s “all a stunt,” patriot petitions and more.

As one level-headed local politician wisely reflected, folks need to realize the lawsuit is not about shutting down Naval Air Station Whidbey Island; it is about whether the EIS and attendant record of decision properly followed the law.

The sudden hyperbolic reaction seems to reveal a suppressed sense of fear in the psyche that maybe the Navy has cut legal corners, maybe it has been a bit too cavalier with the facts or even misrepresented or ignored relevant science.

If so, there will be adjustments in Growler activities in Washington state — changes that could protect civilian life as well as our unique environment and vulnerable wildlife. We’ll see. The courts will decide that, exactly as it is and should be under our U.S. Constitution.

So settle down, take a deep breath north islanders. Whidbey and the world will somehow move past this and survive in spite of the teeth-gnashing and sweaty hand-wringing. Meanwhile, let’s respect each other’s rights to fight for — rather than against — our community, which is exactly what COER is doing, side by side with the state’s attorney general.

Robert Wilbur

President, COER

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Lack of Christian values is the problem, not guns

Editor, We had another shooting and all the anti-gun, anti-Second Amendment people… Continue reading

Letter: Consequences of gun violence far reaching

Editor, As I sit typing this letter, the news media are reporting… Continue reading

Letter: Democrats are harassing Trump for his actions

Editor, Looking at the letters from last week, I noticed one that… Continue reading

Letter: Congratulations, Mayor Severns, on re-election

Editor, I would like to publicly congratulate Bob Severns for winning re-election… Continue reading

Letter: Thankful for voter support in bid to seek re-election

Editor, I want to take this opportunity to thank those who supported… Continue reading

Letter: Permit would allow Navy to discharge chemicals

Editor, The EPA has proposed a stormwater discharge permit for Navy discharges… Continue reading

Letter: Carbon tax a way to get biz, people to alter habits

Editor, This is in response to the Nov. 6 South Whidbey Record… Continue reading

Letter: Event slated to explain taxes and assessments

Editor, The Island County Assessor’s Office has been invited by the Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Citizens should ‘wake up,’ support a carbon fee bill

Editor, It was the Sunday after the global climate strike inspired by… Continue reading

Letter: Fire commissioners have been fiscally prudent

Editor, I would like to clear up some items that have been… Continue reading

Letter: Navy withheld info on water contamination

Editor, The Navy found PFAS chemicals in water coming from its base… Continue reading

Letter: Congress should ban PFAS in firefighting foam

Editor, Recently I attended an informative meeting hosted by the local greening… Continue reading