Publisher’s Column: Hold newspapers accountable, yes, but see social media spin for what it is


When Langley Mayor Tim Callison sent the South Whidbey Record a $64 bill last week for time a reporter spent interviewing the city attorney in February, it was to get Editor Justin Burnett’s attention.

That’s what Callison said Monday — but only after regional TV reporters, the Seattle Times and even the Columbia Journalism Review jumped on the story.

On Saturday night, though, Langley’s finance director and city clerk emailed a response to Friday’s article on Callison and laid out a much different thought process that led the mayor to personally email the bill to The Record.

“If I had a legal dispute with one of my neighbors and my other neighbor wanted to know what was going on and called my attorney to get information and I was billed for that time, I would be understandably angry,” said city employee Debbie Mahler. “That is why I took the issue to Mayor Callison for action.”

“To then write a one sided story in the paper was pure sensationalism to sell more papers and keep controversies stirring in the community,” Mahler wrote. “It is a wonder that we can still get people to run for election and serve.”

Mahler’s letter doesn’t make it sound like the bill was intended to be merely an attention-grabber.

Nor did it seem the mayor was kidding when he personally emailed the invoice to The Record, and said, “Please remit the amount of $64 to the City,” followed by, “as a reminder, the City Attorney works for the City of Langley and is not a free public resource.”

In fact, Callison doubled down over the weekend with a Facebook post on his personal page criticizing The Record and Burnett and justifying his decision to send the invoice. Callison’s post led to a bevy of responses, mostly from supporters, including former mayor and businessman Neil Colburn. Colburn accused Burnett of taking “cheap shots” and “attacking” Callison. Among the 50 people who liked Callison’s Facebook post were Island County Commissioner Jill Johnson and state Rep. Dave Hayes, neither of whom weighed in on the debate.

It’s apparent that Callison now understands that billing The Record was wrong and a violation of press freedom. Instead of admitting it, though, he contends that he never meant for the newspaper to pay the bill in the first place.

I don’t take issue with newspapers and reporters being held accountable for their reporting, they should be. Burnett concedes his biggest regret is not picking up the phone and calling Callison before Saturday’s story ran. A lapse in judgment on his part, yes. Taking that one step would have closed a point of attack by the mayor and his supporters. However, there was no reason to doubt that Callison was anything but serious about billing the newspaper.

Everyone, elected officials included, has the right to complain online that he or she is being unfairly criticized by the media and to present his or her own version of a story. To that end, social media has become a place for what sometimes amounts to seriously calculated campaigns to discredit newspapers and journalists. We see this not only happening locally, but across the country and even in the White House.

It makes a reporter’s job more complicated, to be sure, but it let’s them know their work is under scrutiny, and that’s a good thing. It means they better double and triple check their facts, ensure their sources are creditable and they’ve spelled every name correctly. Reporters understand that even the smallest mistake or omission may be used to call into question the veracity of their entire article.

With social media now playing an undeniable role in newspaper reporting, we’re seeing a stunning evolution in how we respond to attacks on our credibility. With the election of Donald Trump, there came harsh criticism of the national media for not questioning absurd statements and obvious falsehoods presented as facts during the presidential campaign. Fact checkers now quickly work to verify whether the remarks of the president are true and to inform the public right away when they aren’t.

When the integrity of a journalist and newspaper are being grossly disassembled and savaged on social media as part of a purposeful agenda, silence on the matter is no longer the option it once was.

Readers have a responsibility to take into account the entire picture. Social media has a place, but it must be recognized for what it is — a public relations tool that can be used to deliberately alter the facts or shift the focus from the more serious issue at hand.

In the case of Callison and his $64 bill, that bigger issue was freedom of the press.

At the same time, this newspaper’s reporters and editors must be accountable. If they make a mistake, and we all do, we should own it and correct the record.

And if I go out on a limb to publicly defend my newspaper’s editors’ and reporters’ reporting — and I will — their work better be defensible.

To that end, this team of journalists has never betrayed that trust.

Keven R. Graves is executive editor and publisher for the Whidbey News-Times and South Whidbey Record. He can be reached at kgraves@whidbeynews

More in Opinion

City should stand firm in sewer negotiations with Navy

Oak Harbor officials had yet another financial surprise regarding the new sewage… Continue reading

Sound Off: Built to last, and well worth a million bucks

Living in Central Whidbey, I have always thought that having all those… Continue reading

In our opinion: Holland Happening may have changed, but name should not

Oak Harbor Chamber of Commerce leaders learned that a tulip called by… Continue reading

Sound Off: Holland Happening name is a cherished tradition

By Autumn Sundown During 2019, Oak Harbor’s iconic and beloved Holland Happening… Continue reading

A sad bear, angry deer and Tom Cruise make year memorable

It was an interesting year on Whidbey Island, as it is every… Continue reading

In our opinion: Justices’ rebuke of lawmakers is democracy in action

The framers of the Constitution would be proud to see that the… Continue reading

In our opinion: Shopping locally makes for better gifts, stronger communities

Christmas is a week away, but there’s still plenty of time for… Continue reading

In our opinion: Dealing with domestic violence is often complex

The most dangerous place for a woman is her home. Statistics on… Continue reading

In our opinion: You’re not alone if you are irritated by slow drivers

A peculiar quirk of some Whidbey Island drivers is to travel slightly… Continue reading

Sound Off: SPIN Cafe is in urgent need of a new home

SPIN Cafe exists to serve people in need. Today, SPIN itself is… Continue reading

In our opinion: Remove the politics from development permit decisions

A proposal to remove the Oak Harbor City Council from quasi-judicial decisions… Continue reading