In Our Opinion: Letters to schools misguided but should spur reflection

  • Friday, February 19, 2021 1:47pm
  • Opinion

Both the Oak Harbor and the South Whidbey School districts were recently presented with letters claiming that students are being indoctrinated or influenced in political beliefs in classrooms.

They loudly present as “fact” information that anyone with access to Google can easily show is false or skewed.

In the most offensive line, the Oak Harbor letter faults “readings” on the suggested reading list that relate to racial justice, saying such works “advance an ideology that advocates the dismantling of the nuclear family, gender irrelevancy, racial shaming and so on.”

In other words, these are books that espouse women’s rights, gay rights and Black rights.

These letters aren’t treatises presented by lone crackpots. More than 100 people signed the letters, including leaders of the Island County Republican Party.

The concern about students being brainwashed at school is a complaint from the past. For some people, it’s disconcerting to see students change some of their beliefs as they learn to think for themselves when exposed to new ideas, new cultures and new ideas.

Nevertheless, it’s true that in discussions about politics and current events, teachers should be moderators, referees and devil’s advocates. They should not press political ideas.

The letter to the South Whidbey School Board includes a link to a recording of a local teacher in a Zoom meeting passionately criticizing the former president soon after the insurrection at the Capitol.

While it’s contrary to school etiquette rules to record and post such videos, it’s a good reminder that neutrality should be observed in the classroom.

That doesn’t mean a teacher shouldn’t discuss facts, even those that make a president look bad.

A member of the South Whidbey School Board responded for the board in a intelligent, measured letter that goes over the points without being defensive or shrinking from disagreeing or identifying fallacies.

The Oak Harbor school administration and board members had much less to say, claiming that the board doesn’t respond to comments at meetings.

Others argued that the letters should be ignored in order to deny the writers a public platform.

But school leaders and other local government officials should not shrink from tough discussions. They should be role models and stand for what they believe.

Perhaps the letter to the school board could be the catalyst for a larger discussion about racial and economic justice in the schools and beyond.

Based on these letters, it’s a discussion that is needed.

More in Opinion

Rockin’ A Hard Place | The Rock got great help to take care of itself when needed most

We Rock dwellers enjoy the distance we have from America. It takes… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Letters to schools misguided but should spur reflection

Both the Oak Harbor and the South Whidbey School districts were recently… Continue reading

Melanie Bacon is and Island County Commissioner.
Sound Off: Until all are vaccinated, remain vigilant, patient

Every day I receive heartbreaking emails and phone calls from citizens who… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Offer of towering artwork should not be squandered

Oak Harbor has a once-in-a-lifetime shot at getting a bold, superlative and… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Regional reopening plan doesn’t work for Island County

It’s ridiculous that people can’t eat inside restaurants in Island County, which… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Passage of school levy is imperative, even during a pandemic

Voters who live in North Whidbey will decide whether to return to… Continue reading

Sound Off: Much of school district’s excellence due to levy ‘yes’ vote

Four years ago, North Whidbey voters approved a maintenance and operations levy… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Oak Harbor pro-Trump rally during Capitol siege poorly timed

An angry and violent mob of President Donald Trump’s supporters were still… Continue reading

Sound Off: County needs to respond, in public, in detail

This newspaper published an editorial on Dec. 29, “Public Health nurse exodus… Continue reading

Arny, Matt
Sound Off: Navy committed to environmental stewardship

Numerous area media outlets, including The Seattle Times, have published stories citing… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Public Health nurse exodus is cause for reckoning

It’s not unusual for the state Department of Health to assist a… Continue reading

My wish list to Santa Claus after a very hard Rock year

Dear Santa, This has been a Hard Rock year on Whidbey Island,… Continue reading