Editorial: Health care woes grow

  • Wednesday, August 22, 2007 5:00am
  • Opinion

It was an ill-timed coincidence last week when soon after the Navy announced it is closing its emergency room at Naval Hospital Oak Harbor, Whidbey General Hospital announced it might stop accepting military people and their dependents who are insured by Tricare.

The loss of the emergency room at the Naval Hospital was given too positive a spin by the military, but in fact it won’t affect very many people. The vast majority of patients will still be taken care of in the new “urgent care clinic.” But since the new clinic won’t be open 24/7 as is the emergency room, it’s possible that a few people injured after hours will have to wait longer for help — until an ambulance arrives and takes them to a civilian hospital, rather than being taken directly to the Navy’s emergency room. In the eyes of Defense Department budget makers, at least, the cost of keeping the emergency room open isn’t worth the benefits it provides and the resulting risk is acceptable.

Of greater interest to most military members and their families is Whidbey General’s threat to stop accepting Tricare because of its low reimbursement rate. The government pays only about one-third of the true cost of medical care, and the hospital is balking at continuing to make up the difference. The threat to end Tricare has been made to the appropriate officials, but whether the hospital will carry through on the threat remains to be seen.

At week’s end, it was clear that medical care for the military wasn’t as good as it was before the week started, and it could get worse. Not surprisingly, the blame rests with the U.S. government.

The government isn’t funding any of its medical programs appropriately, whether it be Medicare, Medicaid, or Tricare of the Veterans Administration. In many cases, medical providers are expected to make up the difference. Eventually the providers break from the financial stress, as indicated by Whidbey General’s threat on Tricare. It’s become a game of chicken, where the government cuts payments and dares the providers to do something about it. Whidbey General, for one, has had enough of this game and can’t be blamed for its position. If it can’t balance its budget it will go out of business.

Perhaps our local public hospital is helping to foment a necessary crisis. But it shouldn’t tackle the Tricare problem alone — it could hurt too many local military families in the process. Instead, Whidbey General should team up with other hospitals and medical providers to send the strongest message possible. Congress won’t act unless there’s an emergency, so it’s time to show them that an emergency exists. That can only be accomplished through teamwork.

More in Opinion

My two cents: Change on council is opportunity to move forward together

First off, let me offer my formal and public congratulations to the… Continue reading

Dave Paul
Sound Off: Our ferry system is vital — and it needs reform

We need better ferry service. As you know, we’ve seen far too… Continue reading

Rockin’ A Hard Place: Squanto didn’t live on our Rock, but we felt his generous spirit

Every year as Thanksgiving approaches, it’s comforting to fall back on that… Continue reading

In our opinion: Everyone should shop local for the holidays

Shopping local is always a good idea everywhere, but this year there… Continue reading

In our opinion: Plans to rebuild Windjammer windmill are overdue

Four years ago, Oak Harbor officials’ decision to raze the windmill in… Continue reading

Letter: City leaders should consider changing form of government

Oak Harbor Councilmember Tara Hizon was right on the money when she… Continue reading

My Two Cents: Worth more than the paper it’s written on

I have experienced a wonderful time here on the island. From being… Continue reading

Soundoff: Ferry delays are a dire emergency for Whidbey residents

By Island County Commissioner Melanie Bacon Whidbey Island is the largest island… Continue reading

In our opinion: Fleming, Bobis, Salerno are right for Langley council

The best candidates for Langley City Council are relatively easy to identify,… Continue reading

Rockin’ a Hard Place: How teaching on our Rock became a culture war zone

When I was in my senior year of high school several centuries… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Hoffmire, Mischo, Stucky are right for council

Election season has exposed a rift between Oak Harbor City Council and… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: School board incumbents need voters’ support

The schools need leaders who will work together and get things done, not argue over dogma.