Peggy Sue got released: TV show recounts sensational Whidbey Island murder

Just as one of the parties in a highly publicized murder case was released from prison, yet another TV crime series recounted the sordid story of a 2003 murder on Whidbey Island.

Peggy Sue Thomas at trial.

Peggy Sue Thomas at trial.

Just as one of the parties in a highly publicized murder case was released from prison, yet another TV crime series recounted the sordid story of a 2003 murder on Whidbey Island.

The Oxygen network’s series “Snapped: Killer Couples” ran an episode on Peggy Thomas and Jim Huden last week. The episode will play again Sept. 2.

“Peggy Thomas is best remembered as the drop-dead gorgeous beauty queen who spent time in prison for her part in the murder of her best friend’s husband, Russel Douglas, along with her former lover, Jim Huden,” according to a promotional article about the episode.

The case was the subject of NBC’s Dateline and several other crime documentary series, as well as the book “Practice to Deceive” by the late true-crime writer Ann Rule.

Ironically, Rule devoted a chapter of her book to criticizing a former South Whidbey Record editor for in-depth coverage of the murder case.

Thomas was released from prison this month, according to the state’s inmate roster.

The show focuses on the relationship between Peggy Sue Thomas, former Ms. Washington, and James Huden, a musician in a band.

After years on the run, Huden was convicted in 2012 of murdering 32-year-old Russel Douglas, a father of two.

Thomas was accused of luring Douglas to a secluded area in Freeland the day after Christmas with the promise of a gift; Thomas denied this account.

Huden shot Douglas between the eyes as he sat in his vehicle.

Huden fled to Mexico but was finally caught and prosecuted nine years later. A jury in Island County Superior Court convicted Huden of first-degree murder. The judge handed him an exceptional sentence of 80 years in prison.

The motive for the murder was never absolutely clear. The prosecutor’s sentencing memorandum asserts that Huden believed Douglas was abusive to his children and that “murdering Douglas would serve as a proxy killing of Huden’s own abusive father.”

Huden did not know Douglas; Thomas provided the only link between Huden and Douglas. She worked as a hairdresser in Langley for Douglas’ estranged wife, Brenna Douglas.

The prosecutor offered Huden a plea bargain if he would explain Thomas’ alleged role in the murder, but he never said anything against her.

Thomas pleaded guilty to rendering criminal assistance under a plea bargain and was sentenced to four years in prison. Under the agreement, she admitted to helping Huden after the murder.

At the sentencing hearing, however, Thomas’ defense attorney argued that she was innocent and pointed a finger at Brenna Douglas, suggesting that she may have been involved along with Huden.

 

More in News

Bowman Bay diver still missing

Local rescue teams searched for hours Sunday night looking for a 67-year-old… Continue reading

Suspicious botanist, invisible guests, satanic voicemail reported | Island Scanner

The following reports were compiled from calls made to the Island County… Continue reading

Photo by Heather Mayhugh
Stuart Peeples demonstrates how to enter Heather Mayhugh's wheelchair van. In recent months, while navigating the new Mukilteo ferry terminal, Mayhugh has struggled to unload her clients who need access to the restroom.
ADA concerns cited about new ferry terminal in Mukilteo

Advocates feel not enough thought went into improving the new terminal’s accessibility problems.

Bystanders perform CPR on grocery store shopper

Two men helped a fellow grocery shopper at Saar’s last week by performing CPR after he collapsed.

Oak Harbor business owner killed in crash

The owner of an Oak Harbor brewing company was killed in a motorcycle accident in Yakima County.

No serious injuries reported in Bayview Road accident

The drivers of two vehicles that collided in South Whidbey Saturday were not seriously injured.

Photo by Rebecca Powers
Apartment fire injures one, displaces nine

Nine people were displaced after a fire swept through an apartment building… Continue reading

Photo by Sara Hogarth
Crews put out grass fire

A possible mishap with a lawn mower sparked a half-acre fire on Green Valley Road on Friday morning.

Guns found buried under shed, in flower pot | Island Scanner

Sunday, June 27 At 9 a.m., an Eastpoint Drive resident reported that… Continue reading

Most Read