Appeals court affirms ruling in LIHI case

The appellate court agreed with the former county judge’s ruling that the proposed project did not conform to the city’s zoning code.

A judge’s decision to reverse the City of Oak Harbor’s approval of a low-income project downtown was affirmed by the Washington Court of Appeals.

In an unpublished opinion released this month, the appellate court agreed with former Island County Superior Court Judge Alan Hancock’s ruling that the project proposed by the Low Income Housing Institute did not conform to the city’s zoning code for the downtown area.

The lawsuit under the Land Use Petition Act was brought by the Oak Harbor Main Street Association, a group of downtown merchants, against the city and Low Income Housing Institute’s architect for the project.

It’s unclear whether the institute will appeal to the state Supreme Court or what will happen with the property adjacent to Hal Ramaley Park on Bayshore Drive. Officials from the institute didn’t immediately return requests for comment.

An official previously said more than $1.5 million was spent on the project.

The Low Income Housing Institute proposed building a 50-unit project for low-income residents, with a significant percentage earmarked for veterans.

Oak Harbor planning staff, the hearings examiner and the majority of city council members concluded that the proposed development conformed to city code. They found that the project should be considered mixed-use and conformed to central business district zoning even though only 2.8 percent of the 40,000-square-foot building would be retail space.

Hancock, however, found that the code does not allow developments that are primarily dwelling units. The appeals court agreed.

“Under its plain language, Oak Harbor Municipal Code requires mixed use developments in the CBD,” the opinion states. “However, when a development’s predominant use is residential, it must be located in the CBD’s designated subdistricts CBD-1 or CBD-2.”

More in News

Coupeville Middle School students are returning to campus, but not for class

Students in grades 6-8 will return to campus on March 8 in the afternoons for two days a week.

Camano man accused of murder appears in court

The man was accused of shooting two people, killing one, at a Camano Island home on Feb. 28.

House passes ban on certain police use-of-force tactics

Chokeholds are prohibited, car are chases limited and military equipment is not allowed.

High court ruling in drug possession case has multitude of implications

Sheriff Rick Felici said an inmate at the jail on a felony drug possession case would be released.

UW professor floats idea for tunnel between Whidbey, Mukilteo

The underwater alternative to the state’s ferry system involves a tunnel 610 feet below sea level.

WhidbeyHealth EMS, North Whidbey Fire and Rescue, a Navy Search and Rescue team and state parks personnel all responded to the call for help. Photo provided by NWFR.
With tide rising, girl, 10, rescued from mud Sunday

The water was up to the girl’s shoulders by the time rescuers were able to free her.

Nine deer, including these three, showed up at Coupeville Town Hall on Feb. 23. Photo by Emily Gilbert/Whidbey News-Times
Deer ordinance may be in the works for Coupeville

One resident said the sheer amount of deer urine is “overwhelming” and creates puddles at his door.

The Whidbey Scenic Isle Way runs through Greenbank, with water views. Photo by Sherrye Wyatt
Scenic byway earns national designation

T he Cascade Loop, including the Whidbey Scenic Isle Way, is now a National Scenic Byway.

Most Read