Letter: Tyranny is just fine when it works for Republicans


I was intrigued by Ed Hickey’s May 5 letter to the editor. In it, he seemed to imply that nefarious Democrats support statehood for Washington, D.C. in an attempt to cement “perpetual rule of our country under Democrat socialism.”

A similar ploy, I imagine, to when in 1889 Republicans created six new states in less than a year, sending 12 new Republican senators to Congress. And this despite the fact that some of these new states had populations smaller than that of an average county in Massachusetts.

But Mr. Hickey need not worry. Statehood for D.C. is unlikely to happen anytime soon, and the Republican advantage in the Senate seems quite safe. As it stands today, the 50 Republican senators represent 40 million fewer citizens than do the 50 Democratic senators, making the Senate a rather undemocratic institution, something which Republicans intend to protect.

It will require more than one new Democratic-leaning state to threaten that advantage.

Personally, I believe that statehood for D.C. is fair and just. The district has a population larger than that of either Wyoming or Vermont. While these two states each have two senators and one member of the house, while D.C. is left with one delegate with limited voting rights.

I think most of us would agree that this constitutes taxation without representation, something which the founders called tyranny.

It would seem, then, that national Republicans, and presumably Mr. Hickey, are willing to countenance tyranny to protect a Republican advantage in an institution which is currently quite undemocratic.

Dr. Bernd J. Fischer

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Ask Island County commissioners to remove loophole

Editor, A persistent drum beat in these parts warn of our disappearing… Continue reading

Letter: Putting people into groups of color ‘divisive’

Editor, In his letter to the editor, Michael King says that a… Continue reading

Letter: Coalition found location for right price at right time

Editor, This letter comes in response to Mr. Flaaten’s letter regarding the… Continue reading

Letter: In agreement with positions stated in letters

Editor, This is in response to three letters to the editor published… Continue reading

Letter: Be honest: It feels good to be white, feel superior

Editor, I don’t understand why you give space to Michael Bradley’s rants… Continue reading

Letter: Extending liberty, justice to all is justifiable goal

Editor, As an older white guy, age 73, I’m amazed and befuddled… Continue reading

Letter: Clear-cutting may literally leave us a rock to look at

Editor, What’s wrong with us? Witnessing every single year the cutting of… Continue reading

Letter: Name of new park is disconnected, will sow confusion

Editor, Seriously, Maxwelton Trails Park? Once again, a misnomer that will sow… Continue reading

Letter: Is location south of Coupeville truly the best option?

Editor, I invite the readership of your newspaper to assist me in… Continue reading

Most Read