Letter: Questions whether letter to school board is news


Sadly, I have ceased being surprised about opinions being stated as fact and the substitution of uninformed preferences for well documented expert conclusions.

I was surprised that one such letter was given headline status in the Wednesday, Feb. 17 edition, “Letter claims students being ‘indoctrinated.’”

According to the article, there were two main opinions offered by the letter writers: that including information and points of view that differ from their own preferences in public education constitutes “indoctrination,” and that the school’s policies and practices on COVID prevention were unnecessary.

Assuming the Whidbey News-Times representation of the letter is correct, the first claim is self-contradictory and the second simply the substitute of preferences for policies based on the best available data and balancing of competing values, limiting viral spread and having children in schools.

Introducing perspectives and new information, e.g. on racial justice, that challenge commonly held beliefs, e.g. that the nuclear family is the only or best cross-generational social structure or that gender is more complex and fluid than people like me were raised to believe, is exactly how to support the development of critical thinkers.

Excluding such counter-perspectives, as has traditionally been the case, is what produces “mindless non-thinkers.” That there is room for disagreement on every issue raised, including how best to balance competing values around pandemic measures, is obvious. Which is precisely why they should be debated within and outside of schools rather than proclaimed as truth and fact.

I fail to see that the letter warrants front page news — have them publish it as an open letter.

David Allen


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Lauds deputies for restraint during stressful encounter

Editor, I write in response to the article, “Deputies de-escalate encounter with… Continue reading

Letter: Tyranny is just fine when it works for Republicans

Editor, I was intrigued by Ed Hickey’s May 5 letter to the… Continue reading

Letter: George Orwell was a ‘democratic socialist,’ actually

Editor, An interesting phenomenon has been taking place lately: folks are dusting… Continue reading

Letter: District right to stand ground on equity, diversity

Editor, I am encouraged by the strength and integrity that the South… Continue reading

Letter: Kudos to Biden administration for its accomplishments so far

Editor, Hat’s off to the Biden administration. One hundred million Americans vaccinated… Continue reading

Letter: Our country must strengthen the Foreign Service

Editor, As a retired member of the U.S. Foreign Service, I was… Continue reading

Letter: Supports timber industry but not subsidies

Editor, Should we be subsidizing clear cutting of our forest lands in… Continue reading

Letter: Biden is doing what Trump falsely accused of

Editor, For four years, former President Trump was severely criticized by Democrat… Continue reading

Letter: Free speech doesn’t justify racist letter

Editor, I already know that I’m surrounded by racists in this community.… Continue reading

Most Read