Letter: Limiting gun magazine capacity decreases survival odds


As it always happens after a gun-related crime, there is a call for more restrictions on guns and gun owners. Every time a new law is proposed, anti-gun law makers and advocates say this new law will prevent gun violence.

Why is it that after any new law is passed, gun crimes never stop? Is it because criminals don’t care about laws? That can’t be possible, can it? Although, that must be the reason we have criminals. New gun laws never do stop firearm crimes.

A case in point is the two individuals that are wanted for the shootings by Westlake Mall. Both have numerous prior convictions. So by law they couldn’t legally possess a firearm yet somehow they did. There is no way to prevent a person from committing a crime if they choose to ignore the law.

More laws are currently being proposed and will most likely pass in our anti-gun state. One is to limit the number of cartridges in a magazine to 10. This is supposedly the magic number determined by people that think 10 is all the cartridges you should need.

A lot of law enforcement officers carry the popular Glock model 17 which holds 17 .9-mm cartridges and the Glock model 22 that holds 15 .40-caliber cartridges in the standard capacity magazines. Cops usually carry at least one extra magazine and sometimes two. They never know how many cartridges they might need to protect themselves and others.

The same can be said of us civilians. A gun fight against one or more attackers on the street or in your home has no set limit as to how many cartridges you may need. They may run at the sight of your gun or they could begin a prolonged gun battle while you wait for law enforcement to arrive.

A few years ago, I asked a representative in the Island County Sheriff’s Office about a response time to an incident in the county. She said it could take 20-30 minutes depending upon the nearest deputy’s location and disposition. You must be prepared for your own protection and survival. Limiting magazine capacity can decrease your odds of survival.

So why must civilians be limited to an arbitrary limit in magazine capacity? Criminals won’t obey any current law yet you naively believe criminals will obey new laws. The only ones that this and any new laws will affect are the law-abiding gun owners by punishing them for the acts of criminals. To be a lawful gun owner they must purchase new non-standard capacity magazines at a cost of around $20 each. Do you really think a criminal is going to purchase these smaller non-standard capacity magazines to be compliant with the law?

In the Jan. 29 Washington Newspaper Association story regarding gun magazines that ran in the Whidbey News-Times, Dr. Fred Rivara states that, “High-capacity magazines are exceptionally lethal” and “They increase the fatality of any firearm to which they are attached.”

If this is true, then no law enforcement officer should be allowed to use them. The only lethal component in a gun crime is the person pulling the trigger, not an inanimate piece of plastic.

Alan Meaux

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Relax, enjoy the fruits of the Trump presidency

Editor, I feel nothing but sorrow for Larry Eaton. His hollow diatribe… Continue reading

Letter: Sound Water Stewards not responsible for petition

Editor, Sound Water Stewards of Island County thanks all who joined us… Continue reading

Letter: Thanks for sharing and editing my letter

Editor, I want to thank you for publishing my last letter in… Continue reading

Letter: Trump reelection warning is a shameful’tactic’

Editor, Larry Eaton’s letter, ‘Trump reelection is a chilling prospect for U.S.’… Continue reading

Letter: Seeking an injunction is COER act of desperation

Editor, I just became aware that the Citizens of Ebey’s Reserve decided… Continue reading

Letter: Trump reelection is a chilling prospect for U.S.

Editor, I’ll keep this very short so that the “Forever Trumpsters” can… Continue reading

Letter: Manufactured home zones provide affordable housing

Editor, In Oak Harbor we are fortunate to have many areas zoned… Continue reading

Letter: Romney symbolizes what America was once all about

Editor, We just heard something we haven’t heard in a long while.… Continue reading

Letter: Appreciative of help from 911 responders, kind man

Editor, Gratitude to the 911 responders and, especially, to the wonderful kind… Continue reading

Letter: Don’t see how new charge will help the environment

Editor, My response to State Law SB 5323: I for one and… Continue reading

Letter: Offering ideas for saving Holland Happening

Editor, I am writing to express my agreement with the sentiment shared… Continue reading

Letter: Hospital provided wonderful expertise

Editor, A long overdue letter is submitted to say thank you to… Continue reading