Letter: Captain offers up same old tired arguments

Editor,

I just had to respond to the “Sound Off” article in the Saturday Sept. 28 Whidbey News-Times by Bremerton resident Capt. Larry Salter, USN retired.

From the opening, “Pardon our Noise, It’s the Sound of Freedom” to the close of, “I fully support NAS Whidbey Island and the Growler presence,” we are treated to the same old tired arguments: noise zones around the base; “Hint, hint: It might be noisy around here.”

His comments about NAS Oceana and NAS Lemoore having put up with this sonic abuse for 20 years is justification? “Bottom line — jets are noisy,”and he then goes on with “annual operations” and “landing on an aircraft carrier is hard,” which I don’t doubt, but to intimate that OLF Coupeville is the best place to practice these “night evolutions,” a great euphemism for this sonic abuse at night, is beyond ridiculous. It does get dark in less populated environs.

I think what bothers me most about this whole line of reasoning is the mentality that the military is a sacrosanct organization above any criticism.

The Pentagon is the single biggest consumer of fossil fuels on earth. It ranks 47th as one of the largest greenhouse gas emitters. Look at the history of U.S. military bases all over the earth: They ruin the landscape, pollute the soils and contaminate water and air. Look closely and I think you’ll find that U.S. military bases are strategically located to protect their oil deposits and anything else that may be deemed a “strategic resource of value to the U.S. military.”

Finally, please don’t tell me that the military is here to protect my freedoms in America. Where’s the military when citizens are disenfranchised at the voting booth? Where’s the military when “Water Protectors” are brutalized in Dakota? Where’s the military when citizens are arrested for peaceful demonstrations? Where’s the military when the citizens express their disappointment at being implicitly lied to by the Navy for a factually inaccurate and misleading environmental assessment regarding their “operations?”

You see, Capt. Salter, it’s not just about the noise.

Dan Freeman

Clinton

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Price Johnson has earned the trust of 10th District residents

Editor, As an Army veteran and retired businessman still active in my… Continue reading

Letter: If you need a reason to dump Trump, this is it

Editor, Trump will defend a Confederate statue but not our American soldiers.… Continue reading

Letter: True civility is not about shutting up

Editor, Independence. We pride ourselves as Americans that our country was established… Continue reading

Letter: Proud to support Homola for House of Representatives

Editor, In today’s world of so many unknowns, it’s good to have… Continue reading

Letter: Ken’s Korner management has bent over backwards for tenants

Editor, I am writing in response to the Whidbey News-Times article on… Continue reading

Letter: South Whidbey fundraiser raises $20,000 for schools

Editor, The South Whidbey Schools Foundation thanks our generous community in supporting… Continue reading

Letters: Kudos to Johnson for ensuring CARES funds fairly disbursed

Editor, I would like to thank Island County Commissioner Jill Johnson for… Continue reading

Letter: Voting for Damian Greene would be a smart move

Editor, I was very encouraged to see Damian Greene enter the race… Continue reading

Letter: Fixating on Trump’s defeat is detrimental to the country

Editor, In response to Cheri Filion’s letter to the editor in the… Continue reading

Most Read