Caregiver system just fine as it is

You may not have heard of it, but I-1029, the Caregiver Training Initiative, would, if passed, add millions of dollars to Washington’s already strained budget and make it more expensive and difficult for residents to care for themselves and their loved ones.

In January the Legislature will meet, facing a revenue shortfall of more than $3 billion. I-1029 would require more training and federal background checks for most long-term care providers. The state Office of Financial Management estimates this initiative would cost the state, through its Medicaid programs, almost $30 million for the first two years, and more after that as our population ages. This doesn’t include the what it would cost individuals who are not eligible for Medicaid, as their homecare agencies are forced to pass on the huge cost of about $1,500 per caregiver.

So, is this measure really necessary?

Of course people who need help should be able to expect competent, ethical caregivers. But caregivers are already required to have training and state criminal background checks. There is no good evidence that the public is being harmed by the current system or that the initiative would improve matters.

The Spokesman Review said it best: “If the evidence showed that the public was endangered by the current system, I-1029 might be needed. Right now, the case hasn’t been made, and Washington’s economic condition won’t tolerate millions in added costs on the strength of anecdotes and speculation.”

Sharon Emerson, RN

Jeanne Lepisto, RN

Island Home Nursing, Freeland

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Island needs, deserves quality local health care

Editor, I will be voting yes for the hospital district levy increase… Continue reading

Letter: Proposition is crucial to maintain WhidbeyHealth

Editor, Hospitals are as important to a community as other major services… Continue reading

Letter: Hoffmire presents brighter, newer vision for city

Editor, We live outside the Oak Harbor city limits, so we can’t… Continue reading

Letter: Coupeville school challengers have partisan agenda

Editor, Ward Sparacio, a candidate for Coupeville School Board, says in his… Continue reading

Letter: Diamond, Mann understand complex job

Editor, I’m writing in support of Erik Mann and John Diamond for… Continue reading

Letter: School challengers embrace a dangerous fallacy

Editor, In following the local school board election, I was particularly struck… Continue reading

Letter: Our hospital deserves the full support of voters

Editor, I urge everyone of voting age with a pulse to vote… Continue reading

Letter: Hospital proposition crucial for health of community

Editor, Hospitals are as important to a community as other major services… Continue reading

Letter: Write in Fleming for Langley council

Editor, Write in Gail Fleming for Langley City Council, Position 5. We… Continue reading

Most Read