Case shows inadequacies of animal cruelty law

  • Tuesday, August 29, 2017 2:42pm
  • Opinion

Allegations that a Whidbey Island man killed a dog with a pickaxe in a fit of rage was appalling and chilling. It’s bound to cause an uproar in a community that cares about animals.

Pets are seen as completely innocent creatures that are dependent on the goodwill of people.

You can tell a lot about a person by how they treat animals. Cruelty to animals is seen as a bellwether of cruelty to people, particularly children.

The case against suspect Jonathan Rasmussen highlights the inadequacies of the laws that deal with animal cruelty, though he is also facing additional charges.

Animal cruelty in the first degree covers a wide range of bad behavior, but is essentially about the infliction of suffering. It is an unranked class C felony, which means the sentencing range is up to 365 days in jail.

The good thing about the law is that it allows a judge to impose other conditions. A person guilty of the crime can be ordered not to own animals — which is vital — get counseling and reimburse an animal shelter for costs associated with the case.

Animal cruelty in the second degree is a gross misdemeanor.

The law-and-justice community in Island County has a history of taking animal cruelty cases seriously.

Last year a couple of teenagers were charged with animal cruelty after they threw a live chicken into a fire. This year a Clinton man was charged after he killed a fawn with his bare hands.

It’s easy to rail against animal cruelty or to press for harsher punishment of animal abusers. But the truth is that judges should be able to hand out longer sentences in the truly egregious, the truly appalling cases.

More in Opinion

Cartoon for Nov. 17, 2018

Cartoon for Nov. 17, 2018… Continue reading

Letter: Chief of staff at WhidbeyHealth keeping his door open, agenda transparent

Editor, As incoming chief of staff for WhidbeyHealth for the 2019-20 period,… Continue reading

Sound Off: You can pay it forward on Small Business Saturday

By Hope Tinney When the lists of “best places to live” are… Continue reading

Letter: Sense of community is strong on Whidbey Island

Editor, I recently moved back to Whidbey Island after a number of… Continue reading

Letter: Congrats on the successful effort to reopen pool

Editor, Congratulations to everyone who supported the levy to reopen the Oak… Continue reading

Letter: Island Transit campaign raises awareness about road safety

This time of year, it’s dark when I leave my house in… Continue reading

Letter: With tax losses, fewer tourists, where will money come from?

Editor, I appreciated Maryon Atwood’s Sound Off column of about a month… Continue reading

Letter: Join group, start a journey, expand your mind, heal

Editor, I am hoping that we can leave divisive politics for a… Continue reading

Cartoon for Nov. 14, 2018

Cartoon for Nov. 14, 2018… Continue reading

Most Read