County targets corporate personhood

One of the latest resolutions approved by the Island County commissioners is directed to President Barack Obama and the U.S. Congress.

The resolution asks Congress to prepare and send to the states a Constitutional amendment that would in effect reverse the 2010 Supreme Court decision Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission.

The resolution requests the amendment to stipulate that only human beings, and not corporations, are “persons” under the U.S. Constitution. The resolution also says that “money is not speech and the donation of money to a political campaign is not a form of constitutionally protected speech.”

In this landmark case, the Supreme Court, in a 5-4 vote, determined that corporations and unions have the same First Amendment right to free speech as a living, breathing person. Because of that right, the government cannot restrict these large entities from making independent political expenditures before elections.

Critics worry the influx of cash into political campaigns will give corporations even greater political reach, while the influence of the average citizen will be diminished.

Commissioners Helen Price Johnson and Angie Homola supported the resolution. Commissioner Kelly Emerson voted against it, saying that a constitutional amendment would also affect nonprofits like the Sierra Club.

“Perhaps we should address this problem by creating a government that lacks the power to reward undue influence,” Emerson said.

Emerson said she advocates for a “limited government that cannot determine whether someone succeeds or fails in life,” rather than stifle free speech. Johnson noted that many small business owners across the country support the proposed amendment.

Marshall Goldberg, a member of a local group called Citizens Ignited, spoke in favor of the resolution. The group gathered 1,400 voter signatures in favor of the measure.

“It is incumbent upon all of us to take a stand,” Goldberg said. “(The Island County commissioners) represent our voice in other parts of our government.”

Jeff Lauderdale, the Republican candidate for the Dist. 1 commissioner seat, voiced his opposition to the resolution, saying the signatures only represent about one percent of Island County voters.

“The idea that money is not speech, I don’t agree with,” Lauderdale said. “Otherwise we wouldn’t have the old adage ‘Put your money where your mouth is.’”

Lauderdale said people who support the amendment should send their petitions, signatures and influence directly to the offices that they are trying to influence, rather than asking the county commissioners to intervene.

Such an amendment must be ratified by three-fourths of the states.

At the meeting, Clinton resident Dan Freeman said local elected officials “are our expression,” and reiterated that money is not speech.

“The more people have in the way of property, i.e. money, doesn’t necessarily mean they have my interest, i.e. a human being, at heart,” Freeman said.

Citizens Ignited member Paulette Becker said the huge amount of corporate money in politics is “affecting what people really want” and that “anybody with more money, more assets in this country, will then run our electoral process.”

South Whidbey political gadfly Rufus Rose questioned why the resolution was discussed as a regular agenda item rather than in a public hearing. In advance of a public hearing, a legal notice is published in the newspaper to let people know a particular issue is to be discussed.

“This issue has not had adequate public conversation,” Rose said. “Here you are, going to the president of the United States with no public dialogue.”

Johnson responded by saying that county residents had received sufficient notice, as the topic had been advertised and discussed at a staff work session, and posted on the meeting’s agenda.

Rose also suggested amending the resolution so the request be directed to the state Legislature before being routed to Congress and the president. The county’s resolution was passed without this change.

Voting ultimately is the only thing tabulated,” Rose said. “(There are) all kinds of conversations about money ruining things from both sides, but ultimately it’s the ballot that counts.”

More in News

Three people seriously injured in head-on highway collision Saturday

Two people were airlifted and another seriously injured in a head-on collision… Continue reading

Field carrier landing practices scheduled through Aug. 25

There are carrier-based flight training operations scheduled to occur at the Outlying… Continue reading

Waterfront association offers ideas, plans changes for Coupeville wharf entryway

Small upgrades now, then big changes down the road are being discussed… Continue reading

Barbara Bailey won’t seek third term in state Senate

After serving the people of the 10th Legislative District in the state… Continue reading

Supporters wave flags and signs in support of Navy at weekend rally

More than 100 people gathered Saturday to declare their support for the… Continue reading

Contractor chosen for new behavioral health crisis center

Whidbey Island is a step closer to having its first facility for… Continue reading

Wharf gets rural development grant, Oak Harbor requests still in question

County commissioners have decided to give restorations at the Coupeville Wharf a… Continue reading

Paved Kettles Trail to close for resurfacing

Island County Public Works will begin resurfacing activities on Kettles Trail as… Continue reading

Two transported to hospital after motorcycle accident

Two people were transported to the hospital Wednesday after hitting a deer… Continue reading

Most Read