Letter: Patriotism preferable to president’s ‘nationalism’


Now President Trump is a self-described proud nationalist. Setting aside the term’s connection with heinous movements like “white nationalism” and German “National Socialism” or Nazism, this is still quite disturbing.

There is no simple definition of nationalism. It arose in Europe, in part, as an unexpected reaction to the Napoleonic Wars. Psychologically it was rooted in ethnic identity, a common language, common history and traditions, and common aspirations for the future.

Politically, it was harnessed to promote national self-interest and the principle of the nation-state, or political boundaries which encompass one ethnic unit.

Nationalism is not like patriotism, principally because it is based on ethnic exclusivity, whereas patriotism, which we cherish in the U.S., is based on ethnic inclusivity. In other words, it is possible to become an American, while it is not possible to become a Serb, a Croat, an Albanian or a Bulgarian. You either are or you aren’t.

Patriotism tended to replace nationalism in much of the West in part because of the moderating influences of the Renaissance, the Enlightenment and the French Revolution. In those areas of eastern Europe which were less affected by the above movements, social cohesion continued to be based on ethnicity and religion, often resulting in, as with the recent bloody conflicts in the Balkans, aggressive chauvinism, imperialistic tendencies, militarism and war.

Nationalists gain adherents through vilifying the “other,” and through historicism, or cherry-picking history.

In others words, they attract support through fear and lies, similar perhaps to President Trump’s closing arguments in the run-up to the mid-term elections.

While it is certainly likely that the president does not fully understand nationalism, he seems to have adopted some of its uglier attributes.

Personally, I prefer patriotism.

Dr. Bernd J. Fischer

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Alternative, safe vaccines withheld by ‘big pharma’

Editor, House Bill 1638 mandates the removal of “religious and personal exemptions… Continue reading

Letter: Security of this nation’s borders must be a priority

Editor, We have a very serious problem in our country created by… Continue reading

Letter: Former state treasurer is going against our citizens

Editor, Former State Treasurer Duane A. Davidson is opposed to the citizens… Continue reading

Letter: Wondering if the Navy has problem with credibility

Editor, The Navy Growler EIS makes dubious assertions, as well as verbal… Continue reading

Letter: Exposure to jet noise may have damaging effects

Editor, Noise exposure from military jets has long been shown to cause… Continue reading

Letter: OLF discussion needs to remain in the spotlight

Editor, I just want to thank Congressman Rick Larsen for writing the… Continue reading

Letter: Navy took quick action to address problem of PFAs

Editor, In the Saturday, Feb. 2 edition, Rick Abraham implies that our… Continue reading

Letter: Thank you for hard work work along Madrona Way

Editor, I would like to thank the Island County commissioners and the… Continue reading

Letter: Americans come together to achieve a common goal

Editor, Thank you, Whidbey. I am Charles Monahan, commander of the local… Continue reading

Most Read