Letter: Patriotism preferable to president’s ‘nationalism’


Now President Trump is a self-described proud nationalist. Setting aside the term’s connection with heinous movements like “white nationalism” and German “National Socialism” or Nazism, this is still quite disturbing.

There is no simple definition of nationalism. It arose in Europe, in part, as an unexpected reaction to the Napoleonic Wars. Psychologically it was rooted in ethnic identity, a common language, common history and traditions, and common aspirations for the future.

Politically, it was harnessed to promote national self-interest and the principle of the nation-state, or political boundaries which encompass one ethnic unit.

Nationalism is not like patriotism, principally because it is based on ethnic exclusivity, whereas patriotism, which we cherish in the U.S., is based on ethnic inclusivity. In other words, it is possible to become an American, while it is not possible to become a Serb, a Croat, an Albanian or a Bulgarian. You either are or you aren’t.

Patriotism tended to replace nationalism in much of the West in part because of the moderating influences of the Renaissance, the Enlightenment and the French Revolution. In those areas of eastern Europe which were less affected by the above movements, social cohesion continued to be based on ethnicity and religion, often resulting in, as with the recent bloody conflicts in the Balkans, aggressive chauvinism, imperialistic tendencies, militarism and war.

Nationalists gain adherents through vilifying the “other,” and through historicism, or cherry-picking history.

In others words, they attract support through fear and lies, similar perhaps to President Trump’s closing arguments in the run-up to the mid-term elections.

While it is certainly likely that the president does not fully understand nationalism, he seems to have adopted some of its uglier attributes.

Personally, I prefer patriotism.

Dr. Bernd J. Fischer

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Be more considerate, get rid of your own garbage

Editor, To the inconsiderate “gardener:” Do you really think it is the… Continue reading

Letter: Thank you for attending auction, giving support

Editor, Thank you, to all who attended and supported the Island County… Continue reading

Letter: Seattleite: Need to say, ‘No new jets. No new flights’

Editor, I’m a Seattleite and a weekender on Whidbey Island. My family… Continue reading

Letter: Increase in flights will hurt environment, Orcas

Editor, I don’t own valuable property, or support myself on tourist income,… Continue reading

Letter: Navy, its supporters, are not going anywhere

Editor, For nearly 40 years, we’ve listened to their hysterical garbage claiming… Continue reading

Letter: ‘World Beyond War’ idea deserves consideration

Editor, As a 90-year-old who has learned all of the lessons in… Continue reading

Letter: Needed improvements made at Greenbank Farm

Editor, Cheers to the Port of Coupeville staff. This past year, several… Continue reading

Letter: If you’re a skeptic, read new Climate Assessment

Editor, Whatever your opinion about climate change, the report issued last Friday… Continue reading

Letter: Yes, many people knew flight path, but Growlers came later

Editor, I love jet noise that I am able to quickly get… Continue reading

Most Read