Letter: Navy withheld info on water contamination


The Navy found PFAS chemicals in water coming from its base more than a year ago – but didn’t reveal all that were found. Neither did it disclose that it knew, nine months ago, PFASs had seeped to portions of the aquifer.

In October of last year, the Navy announced that two PFASs had been found in Clover Valley Creek and Lake. However, it was not until October 2019, a year later, that reports were posted on a Navy website showing that six PFASs had actually been found — in every monthly sample from September 2018 to September 2019.

PFAS chemicals don’t break down but accumulate in the body and are linked to health problems, including cancer. There are 114 properties in the Clover Creek and Lake area where water is still used for irrigating and, until news of contamination, watering cattle. The Creek and Lake empties to Dugualla Bay and a salmon restoration area.

The two PFASs the Navy first admitted to finding in the surface water were, PFOA and PFOS. But, also found, in every sample taken from September 2018 through September 2019 were PFHXS, PFHXA, PFHPA, and PFBS—the same “forever chemicals” found in Coupeville’s drinking water now being filtered at the Navy’s expense.

The Navy has been quick to say that contaminated surface water doesn’t mean groundwater is contaminated. But buried within the Navy’s websites are summaries of test results from January 2019 showing the contamination of three Clover Creek area wells with PFOA, PFHXS and/or PFBS. The most contaminated well owner didn’t receive results until October 21, 2019.

Withholding such information denies people opportunities to protect themselves. They could avoid exposures, ask for cleanup, or insist that the Navy replace PFAS containing firefighting foams that caused the contamination.

Most wells sampled don’t show contamination, but all wells haven’t been sampled and PFASs are still seeping to the aquifer—and still discharging to Dugualla Bay and the Straight of Juan DeFuca, public waters classified by the state as “extraordinary” for aquatic life uses, protected shellfish harvesting, and threatened and endangered species.

Rick Abraham


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Congratulations, Mayor Severns, on re-election

Editor, I would like to publicly congratulate Bob Severns for winning re-election… Continue reading

Letter: Thankful for voter support in bid to seek re-election

Editor, I want to take this opportunity to thank those who supported… Continue reading

Letter: Carbon tax a way to get biz, people to alter habits

Editor, This is in response to the Nov. 6 South Whidbey Record… Continue reading

Letter: Permit would allow Navy to discharge chemicals

Editor, The EPA has proposed a stormwater discharge permit for Navy discharges… Continue reading

Letter: Citizens should ‘wake up,’ support a carbon fee bill

Editor, It was the Sunday after the global climate strike inspired by… Continue reading

Letter: Event slated to explain taxes and assessments

Editor, The Island County Assessor’s Office has been invited by the Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Navy withheld info on water contamination

Editor, The Navy found PFAS chemicals in water coming from its base… Continue reading

Letter: Fire commissioners have been fiscally prudent

Editor, I would like to clear up some items that have been… Continue reading

Letter: Congress should ban PFAS in firefighting foam

Editor, Recently I attended an informative meeting hosted by the local greening… Continue reading

Letter: Intercultural learning helps build bridges

Editor, My name is Jin Ming Ma and I have lived in… Continue reading

Letter: In election, avoid council candidates connected to ‘baloney’

Editor, Having attended meetings by the promoters of the Wright’s Crossing debacle… Continue reading

Letter: I-976 would lead to another increase in ferry fares

Editor, Tim Eyman is sponsoring another $30 car-tab initiative, I-976, on this… Continue reading