Letter: Good points raised, but hurt by snide comments


This is in response to Dave Rider’s one-sided letter to the editor, published Aug. 15.

Though he makes some good points about war and peace, training and the potential for mandatory service, his snide comments about those who do not think like he does only serve to exacerbate the problems between the civilian population of Whidbey and military members who come for a tour of duty and then move on.

Exactly why must we look at the question of the Navy on Whidbey from only one perspective — Rider’s?

Let’s examine his claims:

First, the issue began precisely about noise. Many of us came to Whidbey for the quiet peace available in so few places today. We signed up knowing the Navy practices at the OLF Coupeville – with a maximum of 6,000 operations a year.

The proposed increase to 23,700 operations is outrageous, to say the least. I will not go into all the other impacts the proposed increases could have on Central Whidbey.

Rebecca Wagner covered those concisely in her letter printed the same week as Rider’s.

Second, Rider thinks it’s about people not liking the Navy.

What utter garbage. I know of no one who does not support the critical role the Navy plays in defense of the U.S., and no one who does not support essential training for the crews who volunteer to put their lives on the line.

As for “the Growler mission has never changed” – this statement is only somewhat correct.

The mission to serve and protect may not have changed, but the methods by which this is accomplished has.

Growlers are the latest, loudest addition to the war/defense program and the source of the present community conflict.

As for the snide comments about “Internet heroes” and “elitist world view” – Mr. Rider’s efforts to demean those whose viewpoints conflict with his are simply crass. If you want to be heard, stick to the facts.

As Mr. Rider correctly says “this is our community too.” However, in my book, “ours” means not primarily the military, but all of us who lived here before you came, live here now and will live here after you’ve moved on. We do indeed have skin in the game.

Life is not solely about war preparation, but about how to live in peace.

Hilary Turner


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Wondering if the Navy has problem with credibility

Editor, The Navy Growler EIS makes dubious assertions, as well as verbal… Continue reading

Letter: Exposure to jet noise may have damaging effects

Editor, Noise exposure from military jets has long been shown to cause… Continue reading

Letter: OLF discussion needs to remain in the spotlight

Editor, I just want to thank Congressman Rick Larsen for writing the… Continue reading

Letter: Navy took quick action to address problem of PFAs

Editor, In the Saturday, Feb. 2 edition, Rick Abraham implies that our… Continue reading

Letter: Thank you for hard work work along Madrona Way

Editor, I would like to thank the Island County commissioners and the… Continue reading

Letter: Americans come together to achieve a common goal

Editor, Thank you, Whidbey. I am Charles Monahan, commander of the local… Continue reading

Letter: The student who stood his ground was not at fault

Editor, I don’t expect to win friends by saying this, but I’d… Continue reading

Letter: Wording could have people drinking contaminated water

Editor, The Navy and Coupeville’s “path forward” to the solution of the… Continue reading

Letter: Navy would allow toxins to remain in water wells

Editor, The legislators in Olympia are on a rampage right now loading… Continue reading

Letter: We need to take care of place in which we live

Editor, Our behavior has consequences. Our oceans have big problems. I think… Continue reading

Letter: Emergency responders serve community well

Editor, In the early morning hours of Friday, Jan. 25, North Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Breaching dam is best solution for killer whales

Editor, “Urgent warning: Elected officials, if breaching does not begin this winter,… Continue reading