Letter: Concerned by a lack of civil discourse over noise


I am a Navy veteran and served as a division officer from 1968 to 1971. I am proud of my service. When my wife and I picked Whidbey Island to build our retirement home, a bonus was the Navy being here. We did consult the noise map provided by our realtor and were successful in finding a lot where flight operations have a minimal impact.

I am concerned about the lack of civil discourse with regards to the effect the Navy has on our community. There is a need for all sides to come together to determine what is best for Whidbey Island, the Navy and our country.

The local discussion tends to get polarized into only two sides: 1)the Navy can do no wrong and anyone who questions the Navy is un-American and should leave, and 2) the Navy is causing more harm than good and the Navy should leave.

This is a false polarization which doesn’t accomplish anything other than making each other mad.

It seems to me that there really are legitimate and different sides to the issue. On one side, the Navy needs a ready force and requires extensive training to achieve that goal. Landing F-18s on carriers is one of the most dangerous and challenging things our military does. On the other side, there really are negative impacts that result from that training. Noise in excess of 120 db over a prolonged period can be debilitating. Safety issues of planes flying low and slow are real. Water quality, resulting from the use of certain firefighting chemicals, has also had a negative impact.

The current EIS, and Navy’s preferred choice, will increase flight operation at the OLF by 400 percent over recent operating levels. Per the Navy, this will require them to create an APZ at the OLF. If this is done, the county will be obliged to review zoning requirements for central Whidbey and many current uses of land and road locations will be impacted.

This will most likely have a devastating impact on Central Whidbey property values, and subsequently all of Island County, and is not a sustainable solution.

There is another option that is not currently being considered.

What if the Navy decided not to site 100 percent of all carrier based EA-18 aircraft at NAS Whidbey? What if instead, they were to establish two bases, each with half of the airplanes and support staff? If this were to happen, then the number of planes at NAS Whidbey would be reduced by a small amount and training activities could be scheduled so as to not require an APZ at the OLF.

We need some kind of solution where everybody can win. If our electronic warfare assets were not staged in one location the country would be safer — remember Pearl Harbor — our community would be better off and we could focus more on becoming better neighbors, and our politicians who help make this happen could win major points by helping our community and our country.

Art Huffine

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Citizens’ job is to ensure elected representativs are doing theirs

Editor, Is the southern border situation a national emergency or a tempest… Continue reading

Letter: Volunteers for treasurer’s office are invaluable at tax time

Editor, The Island County Treasurer’s Office wishes to extend its annual thanks… Continue reading

Letter: Writer’s information is propaganda, not facts

Editor, In your Dec. 26, 2018 edition of the Whidbey News-Times, you… Continue reading

Letter: Distract, don’t talk about investigation, is a strategy

Editor, I believe President Trump nailed it when he said he prefers… Continue reading

Letter: ‘Angel lady’ who turned in lost purse new best friend

Editor, In early December, I had a quick errand at Walmart, parked… Continue reading

Letter: COER shouldn’t be able to hijack Section 106 process

Editor, Citizens of Ebey’s Reserve, or COER, has hijacked the Section 106… Continue reading

Letter: Disheartened by editorial cartoon on Trump, his wall

Editor, It was disheartening that, when I opened the Whidbey News-Times Saturday,… Continue reading

Letter: Storm should have been front, center on page one

Editor, It is obvious where the Whidbey News-Times’ priorities are when the… Continue reading

Letter: League of Women Voters, AAUW legislative brunch open to public

Editor, Much has been said about the renewed interest in government in… Continue reading

Most Read