Letter: Captain’s job is to follow rear admiral’s orders


This is a response to the June 2 guest column by Naval Air Station Whidbey Island commander Capt. Geoff Moore, titled, “Navy committed to compatible uses.”

I read this column several times to make sure I understood what, exactly, he was trying to say about the Navy’s intent. I found the language more of a misleading “sell” than a clear and concise explanation of that intent.

The tone was one of condescension rather than of a true “partner” in how the Navy intends to be a “good neighbor.” There is verbiage referring to EIS and “operations compatible with current land use and their impacts” before “we make a decision on the distribution of operations between Ault Field and Outlying Field Coupeville.”

“We” assumes this will be a decision made by the Navy. One can conclude that the Navy will determine that its activity has minimal impact on the surrounding citizens and the environment that they live in, that the “distribution of operations” is nothing of note really. That “there is no intent to force the closure or relocation of vital government, community medical and school institutions.”

Nothing is said about the effects of the horrific noise of these “operations” on the citizens. After having experienced the noise from these planes, the captain can claim “no intent,” but the reality is this activity is designed to drive people away. I can’t imagine being in a Coupeville classroom and trying to “educate” with this profound level of noise. I can’t imagine trying to sleep in my own home when these planes are “bouncing.”

I took my grandchildren to Fort Casey while these planes were flying into OLF Coupeville. The noise was such that we just left.

This is not “the sound of freedom.”

The captain refers to Accident Potential Zones, or APZs, as if “an aircraft mishap” were something of no import, that the Navy has defined APZs, and that “it is up to local communities how best to incorporate those recommendations into their zoning and future planning, and to reiterate, does not require current existing structures to be moved or abandoned.”

Would a “good neighbor” blast this level of noise into your home in the wee hours of the morning or put you in harm’s way?

Not to mention the groundwater pollution, or the thousands of “operations,” or the possibility of a “mishap” with one of these planes falling out of the sky, or the reality of being driven from your home by sonic abuse.

Rear Adm. Peter Fanta, in a moment of candor, said, “The service was adopting a philosophy of increased lethality and three ways to kill everything. I realize that might not be the nicest way to talk about things, but folks, our job is to kill people and break their toys, there’s nothing else in the world that matters.”

This admiral is Capt. Geoff Moore’s boss, and Capt. Moore will follow orders.

As a citizen, I am not anti-defense, I am opposed to being “collateral damage” to arrogance.

Dan Freeman


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Wondering if the Navy has problem with credibility

Editor, The Navy Growler EIS makes dubious assertions, as well as verbal… Continue reading

Letter: Exposure to jet noise may have damaging effects

Editor, Noise exposure from military jets has long been shown to cause… Continue reading

Letter: OLF discussion needs to remain in the spotlight

Editor, I just want to thank Congressman Rick Larsen for writing the… Continue reading

Letter: Navy took quick action to address problem of PFAs

Editor, In the Saturday, Feb. 2 edition, Rick Abraham implies that our… Continue reading

Letter: Navy would allow toxins to remain in water wells

Editor, The legislators in Olympia are on a rampage right now loading… Continue reading

Letter: Wording could have people drinking contaminated water

Editor, The Navy and Coupeville’s “path forward” to the solution of the… Continue reading

Letter: The student who stood his ground was not at fault

Editor, I don’t expect to win friends by saying this, but I’d… Continue reading

Letter: Americans come together to achieve a common goal

Editor, Thank you, Whidbey. I am Charles Monahan, commander of the local… Continue reading

Letter: Thank you for hard work work along Madrona Way

Editor, I would like to thank the Island County commissioners and the… Continue reading

Letter: We need to take care of place in which we live

Editor, Our behavior has consequences. Our oceans have big problems. I think… Continue reading

Letter: Emergency responders serve community well

Editor, In the early morning hours of Friday, Jan. 25, North Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Breaching dam is best solution for killer whales

Editor, “Urgent warning: Elected officials, if breaching does not begin this winter,… Continue reading