Annexing active farmland for growth isn’t way to go


I strongly encourage our three Island County commissioners to set aside further investment of time or effort on the Wright’s Crossing proposal to annex 250 acres of active farmland south of the City of Oak Harbor in order to build 1,500 new houses.

First, we appreciate the Whidbey News-Times’ continuing fair and balanced coverage of this major proposal.

Many oppose this proposal and reject the flawed assumptions on which it rests. Proponents argue that the city has run out of available land within its urban growth area to accommodate housing needs; that annexing active farmland is OK because farming is dead on north Whidbey anyhow; and that a major new sprawl of 1,500 houses won’t further aggravate already serious traffic congestion because the developer has offered vague promises of “mitigation” magic.

None of this is true. The city has plenty of land to accommodate projected growth — as was just freshly quantified in December 2016. If you think ag is dead, ask a farmer friend, visit a farmer’s market or just take a nice drive and look around.

And do you really think that building 1,500 houses south of the city won’t seriously worsen our existing traffic bottlenecks, particularly since the big job growth is in northern Oak Harbor at the Naval Air Station Whidbey Island?

Many of us are quite disappointed that the City of Oak Harbor endorsed this proposal, given how out-of-place it is and its many fatal flaws. We believe we can do far better. We embrace a future with aggressive growth densities within urban areas to support thriving downtown economies and a vibrant rural economy — and the essential farmland base it requires.

They are two sides of the same coin of smart growth.

Our three Island County Commissioners are scheduled to decide how to proceed with this on Nov. 7, and all three have stated publicly that they intend to set this aside and focus in 2018 on addressing impediments to building out the available lands within the existing urban growth areas of the City of Oak Harbor — and other municipalities — through strengthened “infill” strategies.

We strongly endorse their approach, believing it squarely hits the nail on the head. Please express your support to each of them for this course.

Annexing active farmland as the Oak Harbor City Council proposed to the county is not the way to go. Say no to Wright’s Crossing and 1950s-style sprawl. Say “yes” to smart growth and a vibrant agricultural present and future. Support the three commissioners’ stated intentions, and let’s lean into the real housing and transportation challenges in the coming year.

William Stelle

Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Environment is big factor in gun control discussion

Editor, On and on the arguments rage about the Constitution’s Second Amendment… Continue reading

Climate change not due to man, but part of God’s plan

Editor, The coordinated backlash against Commis-sioner Rick Hannold regarding “climate change” by… Continue reading

Protect your Second Amendment rights

Editor, In response to Larry Larson’s excellent letter “If one Constitutional right… Continue reading

Facts do matter when talking climate change

Editor, We wish to thank Commissioner Rick Hannold for sharing his position… Continue reading

Won’t know how much we lost until library gone

Editor, We need to support our libraries by voting yes for libraries… Continue reading

Allegation of wanting to shut down base is wrong

Editor, In a recent guest editorial, Rick Hannold claimed that I wanted… Continue reading

Hannold’s ‘cherry picked’ logic raises concern

Editor, In reference to Commissioner Rick Hannold’s April 4 editorial, I was… Continue reading

Hannold’s climate change claims undermind credibility

Editor, Commissioner Rick Hannold’s guest editorial on April 4 would have been… Continue reading

Will congressman also speak support of pro-life?

Editor, An open letter to Congressman Rick Larsen: At the March For… Continue reading

is it time to get control of property tax?

Editor, In the last two years my property tax bill has increased… Continue reading

Allied Artists is indeed a nonprofit group

Editor, Whidbey Allied Artists is indeed a nonprofit organization and has been… Continue reading

Loan isn’t going to fix the hospital’s larger problems

Editor, The lead article in the March 17 Whidbey News-Times got my… Continue reading